Aerial view of Cape May, NJ and its beachfront
Cape May, NJ · Cape May County

Cape May NJ Real Estate

Homes for sale in Cape May, and what they actually sold for.

$1.39MMedian sold price, last 12 months
79Sales, Nov 2025 to Oct 2026
The Market

What Cape May homes sell for

Over the 12 months ending October 2026, Cape May homes sold for a median of about $1.39 million across 79 MLS sales. Sellers got 98.7% of their final asking price, and the typical sale took about 80 days from listing to closing.

$1.39MMedian sold price
79Closed sales, 12 months
98.7%Sale price to final asking
~80 daysListing to closing
3.1 monthsSupply, Oct 2026
0.566%2026 effective tax rate

These figures are Cape May City only. Most home search sites report ZIP code 08204, which also takes in West Cape May, North Cape May and other parts of Lower Township, so their Cape May prices run much lower. The comparison below breaks it out.

See this month's Cape May market update

Source: Cape May County MLS closed sales via ShowingTime, Nov 2025 to Oct 2026 (median price is the 12 monthly medians weighted by sales; days on market is the middle of the 12 monthly medians). Updates automatically each month. Cape May County MLS counts days on market to closing, not to contract. Tax rate: Cape May County Board of Taxation, 2026.

Price History

Cape May home prices since 2013

The median sold price went from about $455,000 in 2013 to $1.20 million in 2025. Sales peaked at 197 in 2021, then fell to 80 in 2024 and 89 in 2025.

Median sold price by year
Closed sales by year

With 80 to 197 sales a year, one year's median moves with what happened to sell. The 2024 dip after 2023 is an example. The 13-year direction is the read.

See the numbers
YearMedian soldSales
2013$455K92
2014$538K119
2015$510K173
2016$530K152
2017$560K141
2018$589K136
2019$635K153
2020$733K164
2021$815K197
2022$1.13M130
2023$1.18M86
2024$1.04M80
2025$1.20M89

Source: Cape May County MLS closed sales via ShowingTime, Cape May City. Yearly median is the 12 monthly medians weighted by sales.

Which Cape May?

Cape May vs. West Cape May, North Cape May and Cape May Point

They share a name, not a market. West Cape May is its own borough, next to the City. North Cape May is part of Lower Township. Cape May Point is its own borough at the tip of the peninsula. All four are in the Cape May County MLS, so the numbers compare directly.

Map of Cape May City, West Cape May, North Cape May and Cape May Point, New Jersey, with each town's boundary
Town boundaries from the U.S. Census Bureau. Cape May City, West Cape May and North Cape May all use ZIP code 08204; Cape May Point is 08212.
Cape May CityWest Cape MayNorth Cape MayCape May Point
Median sold price, 12 months$1.39M$1.48M$539K$2.15M
Closed sales, 12 months792511012
Sale price to final asking98.7%97.2%98.6%98.1%
Days, listing to closing801176895
Months of supply, Oct 20263.13.62.53.6
2026 effective tax rate0.566%0.672%0.982%Lower Township0.422%
Taxes on the median home~$7,900~$9,900~$5,300~$9,100

West Cape May had only 25 sales in 12 months and Cape May Point 12, so their numbers swing a lot from month to month.

ZIP code 08204, the one most portals use for "Cape May," had a median asking price of about $892,000 across 79 listings in October 2026. That ZIP mixes the City with West Cape May, North Cape May and other parts of Lower Township.

Market updates: North Cape May · Cape May Point

Sources: Cape May County MLS closed sales via ShowingTime, Nov 2025 to Oct 2026, updated automatically each month (all four count days on market to closing); Realtor.com, ZIP 08204, Oct 2026; Cape May County Board of Taxation, 2026 tax rates.

The Town

The southern tip of New Jersey

Cape May sits at the southern tip of the Cape May peninsula and is the southernmost town in New Jersey. About 2,800 people live here year round (2020 census).

Its concentration of Victorian buildings made it a National Historic Landmark district, and the city says it's the only city in New Jersey with that designation. That's also why buying here comes with rules most shore towns don't have.

Before You Buy

Historic district, rentals, flood rules and taxes

The historic district

Before any exterior work on a building in the Historic District, the city's Historic Preservation Commission has to review and approve it, from alterations and additions to demolition. Each building is classified as contributing or non-contributing, so find out which one a house is before you plan changes.

Guide to buying a historic property in Cape May

Sources: City of Cape May Historic Preservation Commission application instructions and Historic Design Standards.

Renting it out

Short-term rentals (under 175 consecutive days) need a City of Cape May rental license before you advertise or rent. The license year runs May 1 to April 30, the unit has to pass a Fire Prevention Bureau inspection, and you need proof of insurance.

The license fee runs $125 to $300 depending on the unit's square footage, plus a $50 tourism assessment and a $25 parking trust fund fee. The city also charges a 3% municipal occupancy tax on transient rentals.

Sources: City of Cape May mercantile license application; City of Cape May short-term rental rules as posted on Airbnb's Cape May host page; NJ Division of Taxation, municipal occupancy tax list.

Flood zones

Parts of the city are in FEMA flood zones, so check the specific property's zone and elevation certificate before you commit. Cape May is Class 5 in FEMA's Community Rating System, which gives flood insurance policies in the city a 25% discount.

How New Jersey's REAL rules affect new construction and renovations

Source: City of Cape May, 2025 flood insurance letter from the mayor.

Property taxes

Cape May's 2026 effective tax rate is 0.566% of market value (the general rate is 1.118 per $100 of assessed value). At that rate, a $1.39 million home runs about $7,900 a year. That's the 5th lowest of Cape May County's 16 towns. Next door, West Cape May is 0.672% and Lower Township, which includes North Cape May, is 0.982%. The actual bill depends on the assessment.

Source: Cape May County Board of Taxation, 2026 Abstract of Ratables.

For Sale

Cape May homes for sale now

Sold

Recently sold in Cape May

1153 Virginia Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold34 photos
$969,000
1153 Virginia AvenueCape May, NJ 08204
2 bd·1 ba
Taxes $3,893/yr
Sold Nov 13, 2026
Sold at asking price
225-227 Windsor Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold42 photos
$2,500,000
225-227 Windsor AvenueCape May, NJ 08204
6 bd·3 full, 2 half
Taxes $8,863/yr
Sold Nov 12, 2026
▼ $250,000 below asking
401 Reading Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold50 photos
$3,200,000
401 Reading AvenueCape May, NJ 08204
5 bd·3.5 ba·2,232 sqft
Taxes $6,031/yr
Sold Nov 5, 2026
▼ $29,000 below asking
1017 Ohio, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold24 photos
$1,250,000
1017 OhioCape May, NJ 08204
3 bd·1.5 ba·1,500 sqft
Taxes $5,491/yr
Sold Oct 30, 2026
Sold at asking price
201 Beach Avenue #8, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold30 photos
$2,900,000
201 Beach Avenue #8Cape May, NJ 08204
4 bd·4.5 ba·2,448 sqft
Condo fee $1,287/mo · Taxes $11,860/yr
Sold Oct 30, 2026
▼ $150,000 below asking
670 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold50 photos
$1,480,000
670 Washington StreetCape May, NJ 08204
5 bd·2.5 ba·3,100 sqft
Taxes $8,471/yr
Sold Oct 29, 2026
▼ $519,999 below asking
901 Benton Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold50 photos
$4,950,000
901 Benton AvenueCape May, NJ 08204
7 bd·6.5 ba·4,065 sqft
Taxes $17,929/yr
Sold Oct 28, 2026
▲ $200,000 over asking
1460 Texas Avenue #6, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold39 photos
$1,250,000
1460 Texas Avenue #6Cape May, NJ 08204
3 bd·1.5 ba·1,200 sqft
Condo fee $498/mo · Taxes $6,274/yr
Sold Oct 27, 2026
▼ $50,000 below asking
519 Franklin Street, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold50 photos
$3,495,000
519 Franklin StreetCape May, NJ 08204
7 bd·5 ba
Taxes $7,845/yr
Sold Oct 20, 2026
▼ $4,000 below asking
1001 Washington Street 1B, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold28 photos
$635,250
1001 Washington Street 1BCape May, NJ 08204
1 bd·1 ba·621 sqft
Condo fee $192/mo · Taxes $2,141/yr
Sold Oct 20, 2026
▲ $6,250 over asking
1223 A Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold36 photos
$1,100,000
1223 A Washington StreetCape May, NJ 08204
2 bd·2 ba·1,252 sqft
Taxes $5,269/yr
Sold Oct 16, 2026
Sold at asking price
1143 Lafayette Street, Cape May, NJ 08204Sold38 photos
$1,671,545
1143 Lafayette StreetCape May, NJ 08204
3 bd·2.5 ba·1,788 sqft
Taxes $5,764/yr
Sold Oct 15, 2026
▼ $25,455 below asking
FAQ

Cape May real estate questions

What is the median home price in Cape May, NJ?

About $1.39 million over the 12 months ending October 2026, based on 79 closed sales in Cape May City in the Cape May County MLS. That's the City alone. North Cape May, West Cape May and Cape May Point are separate towns with their own prices.

Why do some websites show much lower home prices for Cape May?

They report ZIP code 08204, which also covers West Cape May, North Cape May and other parts of Lower Township. The median asking price for that ZIP was about $892,000 across 79 listings in October 2026, well below what homes in Cape May City sell for.

How long does it take to sell a home in Cape May?

About 80 days from listing to closing for a typical sale over the last 12 months. That count runs to the closing date, so the time to an accepted offer is shorter.

Do I need a license to rent out my house in Cape May?

Yes, for short-term rentals (under 175 consecutive days). You need a City of Cape May rental license before you advertise or rent. The license year runs May 1 to April 30, and the unit has to pass a Fire Prevention Bureau inspection.

What are property taxes like in Cape May?

Cape May's 2026 effective tax rate is 0.566% of market value, about $7,900 a year on a $1.39 million home. That's the 5th lowest of Cape May County's 16 towns. Lower Township, which includes North Cape May, is 0.982%.

Is Cape May in a flood zone?

Parts of the city are in FEMA flood zones, and each property's zone and elevation differ. Check the flood zone and elevation certificate for the specific home before you buy. Cape May is Class 5 in FEMA's Community Rating System, which gives flood insurance policies in the city a 25% discount.

Can I change the outside of a house in Cape May's historic district?

Only with approval. Before any exterior work on a building in the Historic District, the city's Historic Preservation Commission has to review and approve it, including alterations, new construction, demolition and changes to important landscape features. Small jobs can be approved by a review committee without a public hearing. The commission doesn't rule on paint colors.

Do you need beach tags in Cape May?

Yes, for ages 12 and up during guarded beach hours, 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m., from late May through Labor Day. In 2026 a season tag was $40 ($30 if bought by April 30), a weekly tag $25, a 3-day tag $20 and a daily tag $10.

Are West Cape May, North Cape May and Cape May Point part of Cape May?

No. West Cape May is its own borough next to Cape May City and shares the 08204 ZIP code. North Cape May is part of Lower Township and also uses 08204. Cape May Point is its own borough at the tip of the peninsula, with its own ZIP code (08212). Each has its own tax rate, rules and prices.

Talk to Adam

Buying or selling in Cape May?

Adam D'Annunzio, Broker Associate with Keller Williams Realty Jersey Shore, works with buyers and sellers in Cape May and across the shore towns.

Text or call 609-604-5958 · Office 609-399-5454

Adam D'Annunzio, Broker Associate, Keller Williams Realty Jersey Shore. Market figures come from the Cape May County MLS and Realtor.com as dated above and change monthly. Tax rates are from the Cape May County Board of Taxation; actual taxes depend on each property's assessment. Historic district, rental, flood and beach rules are summarized from public sources; confirm current requirements with the City of Cape May before buying.